The Siren and the Specter

3.5/5*

Alexander House is the most haunted house in the state of Virginia. David Caine is perhaps the most well known debunk-er in the United States and as such, he is called in to stay at the house and write a book about it. The current owners are hoping that David will be persuaded into believing that the haunting is real, and that the resulting book about the matter will draw visitors/tourism to the home. Is David finally persuaded that ghosts and hauntings do exist? You’ll have to read this to find out!

My brief synopsis above doesn’t do this story justice. Unfortunately, that’s part of the problem I had with this book. There’s a LOT going on-and to be honest? I thought it was too much. I loved the portions about the history of the house, the area where it’s situated, and its former inhabitants-specifically Judson Alexander. I would have been happy with a book about him alone.

I understand that this story has several layers and I respect what Jonathan Janz tried to do. However, I think the focus of this tale became too wide, what with tons of information about David’s old girlfriend, his old friend Chris and Chris’ new wife Katherine, the CRAZY neighbors down the way, the local sheriff, and I haven’t even mentioned the siren yet! I was fine with all of it through about 2/3 of the novel, but by the last third it just got too busy for me. Yes, there were thrills aplenty and lots of surprises, but I felt like the denouement went on a bit too long, and tried to cover too much material.

The writing itself though, was excellent, as I’ve come to expect from Mr. Janz. He created a tense and dense atmosphere-at times I felt I would surely suffocate from it. I also felt the characters were mostly realistic and while David Caine wasn’t perfect by any means, I did come to care for him and I wanted him to pull through. This tale was imaginative and to restate, my only problem was that I wished it had been more focused.

I seem to be almost the only one who isn’t all-out raving about this story, so it’s definitely possible that I read it wrong. Even with my complaint, I still enjoyed the heck out of THE SIREN AND THE SPECTER. You probably will too. Jonathan Janz is always worthy of your consideration and if you decide to give this one a go, feel free to come and share your thoughts with me when you’re done. You can tell me how wrong I am!

Recommended!

*I received an e-ARC of this book from FLAME TREE PRESS via NetGalley, in exchange for my honest feedback. This is it.* (less)

I’ve been anticipating the launch of Flame Tree Press for a good while now, not least of which because it meant brand new books from Jonathan Janz and Hunter Shea. Both authors launched their careers at the now-ancient history Samhain Publishing, and while both have found publishers elsewhere since that publisher’s collapse in 2016, it feels good to have them reunited beneath a common imprint and the guiding hand of editor Don D’Auria. I’ve been waiting for a new Janz novel ever since finishing Exorcist Falls early last year, so turning toward The Siren and The Specter as my inaugural read of Flame Tree Press was a no-brainer.

As expected, Janz delivers a fun, gruesome, and highly compelling read that happily kept me up past my bed-time on a few occasions because I absolutely had to know what would happen next. This is a good and true “just one more chapter!” kind of read.

Noted skeptic and supernatural debunker David Caine is invited by an old college buddy to stay for a time in the Alexander House, the most haunted house in all of Virginia. Built in the 1700s, its owner, Judson Alexander, was the worst sort of man, one who held the village around the Rappahannock River in an iron fist, raping and killing at a whim. His house was a source of bloodshed and torture for a number of those villagers, the land tainted forever. David rightfully expects the urban legends surrounding the Alexander House to be rubbish, but even he can’t deny the quiet ache of his own personal losses that being back by the Rappahannock causes. As events unfold, David’s skepticism is put to the test and soon enough the Rappahannock will run red with blood.

The Siren and The Specter has a lot going for it. As the title indicates, you get not one, but two – two! – supernatural entities to torment our lead protagonist. You also get a fair amount of carnage, a host of depraved sex acts, and a number of ghostly encounters that will make the hair on the back of your neck stand on end. One of the best parts, though, was the sense of history Janz imbues the Alexander House and its surrounding region with, a history that is deeply personal to David and the peninsula where this book is set. The country is young, but the land is old, and the pre-colonial mythology surrounding the titular siren was a welcome counterpoint to the horrors inflicted by Alexander upon his neighbors. What struck me most, though, was the historical interplay between the siren and the specter themselves. Although these are two distinct entities in the mythology of the Rappahannock, both are fueled at opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of both their gender and their bloodlust, one a victim and the other a victimizer. Janz slowly reveals the stories of each in highly compelling ways, using the dual spirits to illustrate mankind’s proclivity toward wrath, cruelty, and the possession of others.

I’ll confess that on first blush, I wasn’t entirely sold on the siren’s involvement in terms of this book’s plot. Initially, it felt like a bit of unnecessary overreach, even a minor element that could have been cut without any detriment to the work. After some consideration, though, I find myself appreciating the thematic importance of the siren more and more, and the things she represents for David as he is forced to reconsider his skepticism toward the supernatural. There’s a strong sense of duality at play in this book, and as a figure herself the siren is emblematic of several things in terms of both plot and character. The Siren and the Specter is very firmly rooted in the Gothic tradition, which demands readers to use their imagination, suspend their disbelief, and accept that there are more mysteries in this world than we can possibly understand. Judson Alexander is the most in-your-face mystery that both David and the reader must confront, but Janz asks us to accept just a little bit more than that as we carry along, challenging us to confront our own skepticism alongside David and accept some additional horrors and wonders beyond Alexander. Both are integral to David and his personal evolution during his stay on the peninsula. And after all, if we can accept the specter, why not the siren?

While there are plenty of Gothic traditions on display here – the fallen hero, death and romance, loss and terror, an emphasis on sexuality, dashes of political violence, an atmosphere of dread, a focus on the architecture of the Alexander House – in the end, it’s this broadening of imagination that proves most fascinating and compelling. In fact, there’s a lot about The Siren and The Specter that fascinates, from the character dynamics and their relationships to Alexander, the perversions of the Shelby family, David’s struggles to be a better man and the appreciable easiness of those around him to call him out on his foolishness, and, of course, Janz’s flair for violence. Janz is not the type of author who gets squeamish writing about blood and guts, and he clearly enjoys splashing around in gore with all the delight of a mad sadist. This is a big win for horror fans, and even when you know certain macabre acts are just a page away, he still manages to pull off a few surprises in each of the big reveals.

It’s clear why Flame Tree Press chose The Siren and The Specter as one of their launch titles, and it’s a delicious springboard into this new imprint. I suspect this book will also (rightfully) earn Janz a legion of new and devoted readers, readers who will enjoy sinking their teeth into the author’s considerable back-list, which will be republished by Flame Tree Press over the remainder of 2018 and well into 2019. Introducing an imprint, and even to a certain degree reintroducing an already established author, with a work of Gothic horror like The Siren and The Specter is a smart move, and one that instills a lot of confidence in this new brand. Get ready to expand your imagination.

It’s March, 2021 and I’m shamefully just writing a review for Jonathan Janz’s fantastic ‘The Siren and The Specter’ which I pre-ordered way back in August of 2018. I even remember being so excited when it loaded on my Kindle…

So, what took me so long? he asks, turning in a circle and waving at all of my digital TBR books stacked up on my e-reader.

That’s the sad truth and reality for many people, but I still want to apologize to Janz, for just how long this took for me to get to it.

So many people told me to get on this, to read it, to discover some of the creepiest moments you’ll ever read – and you know what? They were right.

What I liked: ‘The Siren and The Specter’ doesn’t rewrite the wheel with the basic plot synopsis. Noted sceptic and author David Caine gets invited to the Alexander House, where his old high school friend, Chris and his new wife, live. They want David to write a book about the house to help create a booming haunted house tourist destination.

It’s from that premise that Janz crafts a truly engrossing read. We get to see how Caine moves into the house, meets the various neighbors, some nice, some naughty, and starts to experience things that don’t completely add up.

I’ve loved a number of Janz’s releases and when he brings the characters into the Long Bedroom on the second floor and you see a writer (Janz to be clear) slip into his wheelhouse and churn out some of the scariest and most unnerving moments you’ll ever read, it was perfect. Just stunning.

The book itself moved along at a really brisk pace. This would typically be a book I’d read in a day or two, but with so many other books on the go, I kept diving in and out, but every time I left this world, I wanted to go back, which is always a great thing to discover.

What I didn’t like: Truthfully, I hated the neighboring family. I know it was purposefully done like that, but their story arc seemed to detract from the house story arc (for me at least) and every time they became involved I was annoyed. There’s a reason for it, which plays out over David’s character narrative, but frankly, I kind of wish they’d just not even been a part of the book.

Why you should buy this: I’ve read a number of Jonathan’s books and he always creates such stunning worlds and characters. Much like ‘Children of the Dark,’ ‘The Siren and The Specter’ grabs you and holds you and doesn’t let go. This one had some moments of sheer terror and horror in it that are pretty close to being unparalleled for me. I had a blast with this one and the mystery narrative that Janz added within the plot was great.

Overall, I’m so glad I finally managed to get to this one and if you have it sitting on your shelf, whether physical or digital, I’d suggest you get to it sooner than later.